The other night, my friend’s teenage daughter asked her if she could download a new app because “everyone has it.” She conspired with her mom friend group, and we all advised her to ask the usual questions: What is it? Who’s on it? Why do you want it?
The teen’s answer was a familiar thing even to us adults: “I just don’t want to be left out.”
More from SheKnows
It made me think back to my own childhood. Peer pressure used to look like sneaking into parties, getting in on trends, and drinking before legal. Today, the pressure can appear in new places: group chats and social media posts. New research from Aura, a digital safety and parental control company, suggests that this isn’t just anecdotal; it’s the new reality.
A recent report highlighted by Scripps News’ coverage of the study found that American teens are actually more likely to feel pressured to use social media than to smoke, drink, or engage in other traditionally “risky” behaviors.
The New Kind of Peer Pressure
According to the survey of 2,000 children ages 11 to 17, 44% of teens said they feel peer pressure to be online or on social media, which was higher than those who felt pressure to smoke (31%), ditch class (28%), or drink alcohol (24%).
In other words, being offline is starting to feel riskier than trying cigarettes. And, it doesn’t stop there.
The same research found that more than half of teens reported feeling excluded if they weren’t in the same online spaces as their peers. Some also said social media pressure was affecting their daily habits—including lost sleep (which we recently reported on), skipped meals, and increased stress levels.
This is where things get complicated.
Basically, even though social media is often framed as optional, for many teens, it doesn’t feel that way.
It feels like social survival.
“If You’re Not There, You’re Missing It”
If you talk to other moms in our own group chat or even honestly think about your own childhood, this all makes sense. Friendships used to happen at lunch tables, on the phone, or at the mall. Now they happen in group chats, Instagram comments, TikTok DMs, and private social media circles.
And when those connections are mainly online, being offline can feel like disappearing entirely.
The study found that platforms like TikTok and Instagram were among the spaces teens felt most pressure to join—not necessarily because they wanted to, but because that’s where their friends already were. It’s less about wanting the app, and more about wanting the connection.
When Socializing Never Turns Off
Another layer to all of this is that social media doesn’t have an off button. These digital conversations don’t end when school does.
Teens today don’t just navigate social dynamics during the day; they’re navigating them constantly.
The study found that teens who spent more time online also reported issues like sleep disruption, stress, and feeling overwhelmed by online interactions. That’s not surprising when you think about it. If you FOMO, you’ll stay logged on. The friend drama used to end when you got home. Now it follows you into your bedroom and sometimes into the middle of the night if you don’t shut down entirely.
Why This Matters for Parents
This doesn’t mean social media is inherently bad though. We try not to fear monger here. For many kids, social media can be part of where friendships grow, interests develop, and communities form.
But the Aura study does highlight something parents often miss. The biggest pressure teens face today may not be partying, it may simply be keeping up. And that can make conversations about social media trickier than traditional “don’t drink or smoke” talks. Because unlike those behaviors, social media is deeply tied to friendships, identity, and belonging. There’s some good, not just all bad.
This means banning it outright often isn’t realistic, and may even intensify that feeling of being left out.
Instead, experts often suggest keeping conversations open, asking kids how they feel online, and helping them recognize when pressure is creeping in…
Now let’s get back to my friend’s teen daughter. She didn’t download the app that night. She talked to her about why she wanted it and what she was worried about missing. They reached a middle ground of downloading it, but setting some limits so it doesn’t interrupt with other things she’s doing. Beyond their specific family’s rules, we love the conversations we can have with our kids on these things they might feel pressured to engage in.
Best of SheKnows
Sign up for SheKnows’ Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.
