The California Legislature passed several measures to regulate social media, chatbots for children.
Dreamstime
Dreamstime/TNS
The recent lawsuits by some of the world’s biggest social media companies against a new California law are the latest salvos in an ongoing debate: Are personalized feeds protected under the First Amendment? Google, Meta and TikTok argue in federal courts that they are and that Assembly Bill 1709 is unconstitutional. The law requires companies to provide platforms to children under 16 that don’t use algorithms, autoplaying videos and other features. If not, they are supposed to delete the accounts of any users under that age limit. “Without personalized feeds, millions of under-16 users will struggle to find the content that is right for them amongst billions of videos that are geared toward adults or users with different interests,” Google, which owns YouTube, argues in its lawsuit. “To make matters worse, AB 1709 substitutes the state’s judgment for that of parents, prohibiting under-16 users from accessing personalized feeds even when their parents want them to be able to do so.” The measure is part of a larger effort by California legislators to put restrictions on how social media is used by children due to concerns about their mental and physical health. AB 1709 passed this year and is set to go into effect Jan. 1. First Amendment experts say arguments made by the companies are not new and have so far been unsuccessful in stopping a California law passed in 2024 that also aims to put restrictions on an “addictive feed.” But that doesn’t mean they won’t prevail this time. “There are arguments on both sides,” G.S. Hans, a professor at Cornell Law School, said of the legal challenges. “It’s a close case in part because there’s some uncharted territory.” That’s because the U.S. Supreme Court has declined to issue a firm ruling on if feeds generated by algorithms are protected under the First Amendment, Hans said. The companies argue that they are making choices about how information is organized, shared and displayed on their platforms, which should be protected. “TikTok’s personalized feeds are designed based on the editorial judgments of TikTok’s flesh-and-blood employees,” the company said in its complaint. It said those judgments reflect the company’s Community Guidelines policies, what content it prioritizes and its mission and business goals. Eric Goldman, a law professor at Santa Clara University, agrees with the concerns about the new measure. He views it as the Legislature pushing censorship. “Why does the state have the right to control the manner and substance of the content to users whether they are minors or adults?” he said. Supporters say protecting children from personalized feeds is critical because their brains are still developing, leaving them vulnerable to its features. The author of the new law is a Democrat, but the measure was also backed by every Republican in both the Senate and Assembly. That was a few days after Meta agreed to daily time limits for users under 18 years old, blocks on notifications in the middle of the night and the option for teens to have a feed that is not driven by an algorithm as part of a settlement with California and other state attorneys general. “They have already agreed to restrict their actions in some way,” said Gaia Bernstein, a law professor at Seton Hall University. “So I think it’s becoming a more difficult environment for them to operate in and to make these arguments.” The companies in their lawsuits want judges to declare the law unconstitutional and prevent it from going into effect. In a statement, the California Attorney General’s Office said it was “committed to defending California’s commonsense laws to protect kids online.” Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of UC Berkeley’s law school, said a couple of years ago he thought personalized feeds would be treated as protected. But the blowback against the companies in the public and legal realms has shifted that view. “I think it’s unclear in terms of the First Amendment,” he said. “To what extent will a court regard this as regulating speech or to what extent a court will regard this as regulating a product?”
Related Stories from Sacramento Bee
Stephen Hobbs
The Sacramento Bee
Stephen Hobbs is an enterprise reporter for The Sacramento Bee’s Capitol Bureau. He has worked for newspapers in Colorado, Florida and South Carolina.
——————————————————–
Click Here For The Original Source.