Every third-party risk management (TPRM) leader surveyed had discovered a gap or vulnerability in a vendor post-approval.
That is a finding CISOs should pay attention to.
In 2026 research by CHIME Digital Health Analytics, 102 third-party risk management decision-makers at large healthcare provider organizations were surveyed. All of them said their teams had uncovered at least one vendor gap or vulnerability after approval, and nearly one in five said it happened frequently.
These were not necessarily failed assessments or immature programs. They were organizations that had gone through due diligence with security evidence collected and decisions made. Yet a concerning event still surfaced afterward.
That does not mean the TPRM process failed. The more troubling explanation is that we are asking teams to make increasingly consequential risk decisions based on evidence that is not always comparable, current or directly relevant to the service they are evaluating.
For CISOs, the problem goes beyond vendor oversight. Every vendor carries some unknown risk, and that is unavoidable. The bigger concern is giving executives and boards more confidence than the evidence supports.
Your vendor’s report is not proof of anything
Most teams are not short on vendor provided documentation. They receive questionnaires, SOC 2 reports, ISO 27001 certifications, NIST-based assessments, penetration-test results, vulnerability scans, policies and more.
The harder part is figuring out what those materials actually say about the vendor and service the organization is relying on.
A SOC 2 report, ISO certification or completed questionnaire can be valuable and still leave important questions unanswered. Does its scope cover the service being purchased? Are the systems processing the organization’s data covered? Are important third and fourth parties accounted for? Were the controls that matter to the specific risk actually evaluated, and by whom? What was excluded? How much has changed since assurance work was performed?
That space between having an assurance artifact and knowing how much confidence to place in it is where problems can hide. This is an “assurance gap”: the distance between possessing an artifact and determining that it is fit for the recipient’s actual risk decision.
This is not an argument against SOC 2, ISO 27001, NIST-based assessments or questionnaires. They serve different purposes and provide different kinds of evidence. The problem comes when having the document becomes a proxy for having answered the risk question.
Asking vendors for more evidence won’t close the gap
When teams are not comfortable with the evidence in front of them, the natural reaction is to ask for more. That works until it does not.
The CHIME research found that nearly 55% of surveyed organizations manage more than 1,000 vendors, and almost a quarter manage more than 2,500. Only 9.8% reported having more than 20 personnel dedicated to TPRM. Forty-eight percent said they could not keep pace with assessment volume, while 39% reported backlogs that delayed vendor onboarding.
You do not solve that math by adding another spreadsheet or asking an additional hundred questions.
There is a larger governance issue as well. Approximately 29% of respondents said their organizations had approved vendors beyond stated risk tolerance, while about 23% reported that a vendor incident had caused clinical or operational disruption.
A vendor approved beyond the organization’s stated risk tolerance is not simply a TPRM paperwork issue. It is a risk acceptance decision, whether leadership explicitly recognizes it as one or not.
Meanwhile, the target keeps moving. Vendors add services. Technology architectures change. Access expands. Subprocessors change. New vulnerabilities emerge. AI capabilities are being added to products and workflows at remarkable speed. Evidence that supported a reasonable decision a month ago might not support the same decision today.
Stop calling it vendor approval. It is risk acceptance.
The answer is not abandoning the assurance mechanisms companies already use. It is becoming more disciplined about what those mechanisms actually prove and the decisions they support.
Instead of asking whether the SOC 2 is on file or the questionnaire is complete, teams need to determine whether the evidence covers the service and systems they rely on, how rigorously the relevant controls were evaluated, what was excluded or excepted, and whether enough has changed since the assessment to reconsider the decision.
They also need to know when enough is enough.
That is particularly important when TPRM resources are already stretched. In the CHIME research, 92% of respondents estimated that relying on a single validated certification could save at least eight hours per vendor assessment. Across 100 assessments, that is roughly 800 hours that could be spent investigating exceptions, examining higher-risk relationships, expanding vendor portfolio coverage, and responding to changes that could alter the organization’s exposure.
The goal is not to collect more evidence. It is to make better decisions with the evidence already available and recognize when that evidence is not enough.
A practical starting point is to ask three questions of every approval:
Does the evidence cover the service and systems in scope?
How rigorously were the relevant controls evaluated?
What has changed since the assessment was performed?
Those questions will not eliminate surprises, but they show how much confidence the evidence deserves. If every TPRM leader surveyed eventually found something after approval, that is worth taking seriously. It suggests that completing the process is not necessarily the same as understanding the risk.
The better measure is how much confidence the evidence deserves, where its blind spots are and who is accepting the risk that remains.
Because the worst time to discover the gap between assurance and reality is after an event discovers it for you.
________________
Source notes
CHIME Digital Health Analytics, Third-Party Risk Management Assurance Research Program, commissioned by HITRUST, 2026 (102 respondents at U.S. healthcare providers with $1 billion or more in revenue). The median surveyed organization managed more than 200 vendors per dedicated TPRM professional; 39% reported that assessment backlogs had delayed vendor onboarding or procurement decisions.
Join our LinkedIn group Information Security Community!
——————————————————-
Click Here For The Original Source.
