The use of social media to threaten, intimidate or harass
someone is an obvious cause of concern in our society. Young people
are particularly vulnerable to social media harassment or what has
become called “cyber-bullying”. This concern has led to
some positive legislative changes in most provinces through
amendments made to their respective education legislation and in
Canada through amendments to the Criminal Code. Civil courts have
also been sensitive to online harassment, particularly in the area
of defamation law. However, the incremental changes in the civil
courts and the amendments to education legislation and the Criminal
Code may not represent the best response to cyberbullying. As
demonstrated in Benoit v. Langille (Facebook Group “Stop
Gail Benoit”), 2022 NSSC 374 (not on CanLII), the best
response may be in the form of legislation that is specifically
designed to provide a victim with remedies for cyber-bullying.
In this Nova Scotia case, the applicant used Nova Scotia’s
Intimate Images and Cyber-Protection
Act (the “Cyber-Protection
Act”) to obtain an order for, among other things, the
removal of harassing Facebook posts and to prevent the respondent
from further cyber-bullying without having to rely on the criminal
justice system or to engage in costly or cumbersome litigation
involving the actual posters of harassing, threatening and
intimidating statements.
The applicant had become the subject of cyber-bullying as a
result of having been involved in multiple Court proceedings
related to her mistreatment of dogs. In 2010, for example, the
applicant was found guilty for breaching the Animal Cruelty
Act and for assaulting a peace officer.
The activities of the applicant led the respondent to create a
Facebook group which focused on the applicant and her treatment of
animals. The respondent was the administrator of the group and
people were allowed to join the group and to leave comments, which
were accessible to the public.
The applicant alleged that the comments posted on the group were
harmful because they encouraged violent harm to her or warned that
she should be watched. The comments, among others, also alleged
that the applicant was watching people’s home to observe their
pets in preparation to steal them, that the applicant should be
beaten to a pulp, and that the applicant drove while drunk and
unlicensed. The applicant stated that these posts caused her fear
and anxiety. Accordingly, she sought remedies under the Cyber-Protection Act.
Under the Cyber-Protection Act,
“cyber-bullying” is defined as “an electronic
communication, direct or indirect, that causes or is likely to
cause harm to another individual’s health or well-being, where
the person responsible for the communication maliciously intended
to cause harm to another individual’s health or well-being or
was reckless with regard to the risk of harm to another
individual’s health or well-being.” The definition
includes a non-exhaustive list of activities that could fall within
it.
Section 7 of the Cyber-Protection Act also contains a list
of factors that a Court is required to consider on an application
for an order and what order to make.
Unlike offences prosecuted under the Criminal Code, the standard of proof
under the Cyber-Protection Act is a balance of
probabilities.
In Fraser v. Crossman, 2022 NSSC 8, the
court explained that in order to succeed on a cyberbullying
application, the following four elements had to be proven:
the information in question must be an electronic
communication;
electronic information may be direct or indirect;
electronic communication must cause or be likely to cause harm
to another individual’s health or well-being; and
the person responsible for the communication must maliciously
intend to cause harm to another individual’s well-being or was
reckless with regard to the risk of harm to that individual’s
health or well-being.
The court found that the Facebook posts were an electronic
communication and that the electronic communication was both direct
and indirect to the applicant and others. The applicant was the
sole focus of the Facebook group and the group was open and
public.
The court further found that the communications might cause or
were likely to cause harm to the applicant’s health or
well-being because some of the posts contained graphic threats to
the applicant.
Lastly, with respect to the fourth element of the test, the
court accepted the applicant’s contention that there was
recklessness on the part of the respondent to allow the posts which
created a risk of harm to the applicant. Even though the court
noted that certain aspects in some of the communications post were
true with respect to the applicant having been found guilty of
causing harm to animals and to police involved in animal welfare,
the court found that “…the Facebook group encouraged members
to engage in a new, and disturbing, form of cyber vigilantism,
facilitated by social media”.
In the result, the court ordered that the respondent was:
prohibited from making any further communications that would
constitute cyber-bullying via Facebook;
required to take down her Facebook group;
to take down any communications that were cyber-bullying,
including, but not limited to, Facebook postings that referred
directly or indirectly to the applicant and which referenced or
encouraged violence or threats of violence against her;
to disable access to any communications that were
cyber-bullying if such communications could not be taken down;
and
prohibited from any communications, directly or indirectly,
with the applicant except through a lawyer.
The applicant, however, was not awarded any damages because of
insufficient evidence.
This case demonstrates the effectiveness of legislation that is
specifically designed to combat cyberbullying. The applicant was
not required to engage police or the criminal justice system and
was not required to commence proceeding against all of the
individuals who had posted harmful comments on the Facebook group.
The applicant was only required to commence her proceeding against
the group’s administrator. Accordingly, this case serves as a
warning to online forum or chat group administrators in Nova Scotia
to be vigilant in vetting potentially harmful comments that are
posted thereon, especially if accessible to the public, and as a
shining example of legislation that should be considered by other
provinces. A person who is the victim of cyberbullying ought to
have easy access to the courts and should not be required to engage
in costly or cumbersome litigation to obtain a remedy against
potentially anonymous harassers. A PDF version is available to
download here.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.
——————————————————–
Click Here For The Original Source.
