Follow us on Google News
The Delhi High Court has ruled that cyber fraud reporting mechanisms cannot be used to settle private financial disputes arising from voluntary contractual transactions. The court directed the de-freezing of two bank accounts linked to a ₹30 lakh property dispute, observing that an ordinary civil disagreement cannot be treated as a cyber fraud case without the necessary elements of an offence.
The ruling came after a father and son challenged restrictions imposed on their bank accounts following a cybercrime complaint involving money transferred under a property settlement.
What Did the Court Rule?
The High Court held that the continued freezing of bank accounts was unjustified when the disputed transactions arose from a voluntary financial arrangement between parties who knew each other.
The investigating agency had itself recorded that the dispute did not disclose the ingredients of cyber fraud. The ₹30 lakh had been transferred through banking channels by the account holder or her family members. The court observed that allowing the restrictions to continue would effectively give a private dispute the appearance of a cyber fraud case.
It emphasised the distinction between allegations of fraudulent financial activity and disagreements arising from contractual obligations.
How Did the Dispute Begin?
The dispute originated from a property transaction in July 2013 involving the proposed purchase of the third floor of a property in Karol Bagh, Delhi, along with front and terrace rights. The father had agreed to purchase the property for ₹60 lakh and paid ₹30 lakh as earnest money to the company concerned.
After the company allegedly failed to execute the sale deed, the father instituted a civil suit in 2016. The parties subsequently agreed to settle the dispute through a refund of ₹30 lakh in exchange for withdrawal of the civil proceedings.
A settlement deed was executed on March 16, 2026, and the amount was transferred to the father’s bank account in four instalments on March 17.
FCRF Launches Certified Chief Risk Officer (CRO) Program for India’s Risk Leaders
The father later transferred the money to his son’s bank account as part of a family arrangement.
Why Was Cyber Fraud Alleged?
On March 18, a cybercrime complaint was lodged by the daughter of the woman who had returned the money under the settlement. The complainant alleged internet banking-related fraud, claiming that her mother had mistakenly transferred the amount.
Following the complaint, the father and son discovered that their bank accounts had been frozen and liens had been marked against them. They subsequently approached the High Court seeking quashing of the cybercrime complaint and removal of the restrictions on their accounts.
The dispute therefore raised a legal question about whether money transferred pursuant to a documented civil settlement could subsequently become the subject of cyber fraud proceedings.
What Did Investigators Find?
During the proceedings, the investigating agency informed the court that it had examined the father and reviewed documents connected with the disputed transactions. These included the agreement to sell, orders passed during the civil proceedings, the settlement deed and CCTV footage.
The agency stated that it had no objection to the accounts being de-frozen. However, it submitted that the disputed ₹30 lakh should remain on hold until the inquiry was completed.
The court considered these submissions alongside the documentary record and the circumstances surrounding the transfers.
What Happened to the Accounts?
The High Court directed that both bank accounts be de-frozen, rejecting the continuation of restrictions arising from the cybercrime complaint.
The court also declined to maintain a lien over the disputed amount. However, it did not quash the cybercrime complaint itself, leaving the parties free to pursue appropriate legal remedies.
The decision distinguishes the removal of financial restrictions from the separate question of whether a complaint should remain pending.
Why Is the Ruling Significant?
The decision addresses the legal limits of using cybercrime reporting and account-freezing procedures in disputes involving voluntary financial transactions.
It makes clear that the existence of a disagreement over money does not, by itself, establish cyber fraud, particularly where the transactions arise from documented contractual arrangements.
The ruling also highlights the importance of examining the underlying transaction before continuing restrictions on bank accounts. In this case, the documented property settlement, banking transactions and investigating agency’s findings were central to the court’s decision.
The judgment reinforces the distinction between civil remedies available in private financial disputes and the use of cybercrime procedures intended to address fraudulent activity.
Click Here For The Original Source.
——————————————————–
