Hospital boards should have a drill-measured response time to know how quickly the emergency department can view a patient’s allergy profile, order a blood test, or provide a scan to a physician if a hospital computer system crashes tonight. Medicare should require these hospitals to demonstrate that they are capable of responding within that time frame.
On November 16th, a Kazakh citizen named Roman Khlynovskiy, age 43, was brought to trial in Federal Court in Knoxville, TN; following his extradition from Italy. He has been charged by federal prosecutors as being part of the “8-Digits Team,” an alleged ransomware/extortion organization associated with both INC and Lynx which attacked hospitals and additional types of health care organizations as well as schools in at least six states. The U.S. Justice Department has credited Italian officials as well as investigators from Ukraine and Lithuania for assisting in the investigation. Trial is set to begin on January 19th. Khlynovskiy is considered to be innocent.
Prosecutors are alleging that the group made a demand of over $500 million and stated that they had access to over 70 million confidential health records. This represents what was being asked for by the group, as well as what the group claimed to have obtained. One of the allegations against Khlynovskiy is that he would release nonconsensual intimate images, which falls within the scope of the TAKE IT DOWN Act. When a hospital is able to restore its systems, it can allow its patients to receive care again. However, when a patient’s personal data has been compromised, there is no way for the patient to regain control over that data.
A defendant is brought before a judge through extradition. However, a different type of preparation is required to continue operation of an emergency department. Two emergency departments located within close proximity of a health system affected by ransomware were studied and both experienced increased patient volume and extended wait times during the time period of the disruption. When a hospital loses the capacity to admit patients it can transfer that emergency to another hospital.
The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has provided voluntary cybersecurity objectives for the health care industry. Congress needs to mandate that Medicare requires hospitals and key contracting companies to provide evidence that they are capable of protecting patient data and continuing to function in the event of an outage. Congress must also mandate that hospitals conduct independent testing on their ability to restore backup data; then report publicly on whether each hospital passed the test, how fast each hospital was able to return to full functionality following a disaster, and within what timeframe any issues identified in the test must be corrected. Additionally, board members must receive reports on what the testing results indicate regarding the quality of bedside care being provided. For example, testing results may reveal that nurses cannot verify medication orders if the primary system used by the hospital is down.
Each state needs to develop regional emergency drills that include all the different types of medical care organizations such as hospitals, ambulance services, labs, and pharmacies. During these drills, each organization should be presented with a scenario where multiple organizations lose the ability to use the same supplier at the same time. The question then becomes; who takes the diverted patients? How do doctors get emergency lab test results? And who tells families what to do next? Congress must provide funding for shared recovery resources for rural and safety-net hospitals. A town with only one emergency room must have the tools available to achieve the standard just as much as it must have the standard.
The patients that have had their records stolen also need help. For example, during the separate 2024 Change Healthcare breach event, Change Healthcare reported to the federal government that approximately 192.7 million individuals had been impacted. Congress should establish requirements for breach response plans that include providing patients with regular updates (using plain language) as new information becomes available, establishing a telephone hotline for patients seeking assistance, and assisting patients in correcting errors on their records caused by someone using their identity to receive care. While credit monitoring is useful, it is unlikely to be of much use to a patient attempting to remove a false diagnosis from a medical chart or responding to threats to disclose sensitive personal information.
The Department of Justice should continue to build upon the collaborative efforts that led to the extradition of Khlynovskiy to Tennessee, by creating ongoing agreements for the preservation of evidence in a timely manner and the identification and recovery of proceeds from illegal activities through the use of judicial authorization. Similarly, hospital administrators are working against a clock of their own. They must be prepared to inform patients prior to the next power outage as to how their health care needs will be met that evening and as to who will assist them the following day should their patient files become compromised.
Fransiscus Nanga Roka
Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya and Managing Partner Law Firm Victorious Indonesia
Click Here For The Original Source.
——————————————————–
