Man accused of sexually abusing family member after online predator-catching group confronts him at Scottsdale hotel | #childpredator | #onlinepredator | #sextrafficing


The online group Predator Poachers helped lead police to a suspect accused of child sex crimes. How does Arizona law view the evidence they collect?

PHOENIX — A Phoenix man is behind bars, accused of sexually abusing a family member after an online predator-catching group confronted him at a Scottsdale hotel in an encounter streamed on the internet.

Michael Alen Smith, 50, was arrested after members of Predator Poachers, a group known for conducting undercover investigations targeting suspected child predators, arranged to meet him at a Scottsdale hotel.

According to court documents, Smith believed he was meeting a mother who would allow him to engage in sexual activity with her 12-year-old daughter. Instead, the supposed child was an adult decoy working with Predator Poachers.

The confrontation ultimately led to disturbing allegations involving Smith’s teenage family member and raised broader questions about the growing popularity of online vigilante groups and whether evidence they collect can withstand scrutiny in criminal court.

According to Scottsdale police, members of Predator Poachers began communicating with Smith through FetLife, an adult-oriented social networking platform, before continuing their conversations on Telegram.

Over approximately two weeks, investigators say Smith exchanged sexually explicit messages with someone he believed was the mother of a 12-year-old girl.

Police allege Smith repeatedly expressed interest in engaging in sexual acts with the child and arranged to meet the mother and daughter at the Scottsdale hotel on November 13.

When Smith arrived, members of Predator Poachers were waiting with cameras recording.

During an approximately two-hour confrontation, Smith allegedly admitted to sexually abusing a teenage family member since the victim was approximately six.

According to the probable cause statement, Smith claimed his estranged wife was also involved in the alleged abuse.

Investigators say Smith described multiple incidents involving inappropriate sexual contact with a minor.

The group eventually contacted Scottsdale police, who responded to the hotel and arrested Smith.

Investigators subsequently obtained search warrants for Smith’s cellphone and Phoenix residence.

According to court documents, detectives discovered suspected child sexual abuse material associated with Smith’s Telegram account.

Smith was booked on multiple felony allegations, including child molestation, luring a minor for sexual exploitation, attempted sexual conduct with a minor and sexual exploitation of a minor.

While Predator Poachers’ confrontation resulted in Smith’s arrest, the case highlights an increasingly common question for law enforcement agencies and prosecutors: What happens when private citizens conduct investigations that would traditionally be handled by police?

Arizona criminal defense attorney Josh Kolsrud, a former prosecutor, says these types of operations are not new, but social media has helped them attract significantly larger audiences.

“Since the advent of the internet, they have become more popular, and because of that, you do see a lot more of this happening than you did, let’s say, 10, 15, 20 years ago,” Kolsrud said.

Groups like Predator Poachers often pose as minors or parents willing to facilitate sexual encounters with children. Their conversations with suspects can continue for days or weeks before a meeting is arranged.

When the suspect arrives, the group confronts the individual, frequently recording or livestreaming the interaction before contacting police.

Kolsrud says evidence collected by these groups can be admissible in criminal proceedings, even though the individuals conducting the investigations are not sworn law enforcement officers.

However, that evidence is not automatically immune from legal challenges.

Defense attorneys can scrutinize the credibility of the people collecting it, how digital records were preserved and whether the evidence accurately represents the full interactions between the parties.

One of the most significant legal distinctions between police-run undercover operations and investigations conducted by independent civilian groups involves entrapment.

Under Arizona law, an entrapment defense generally requires that law enforcement officers or individuals acting as their agents induced someone to commit a crime they otherwise would not have committed.

Kolsrud says that distinction could be particularly important in Smith’s case.

“If law enforcement wasn’t involved until after the communications took place, if they weren’t directly communicating or directing this vigilante group to do anything, then it’s very unlikely that entrapment could ever apply in a case like this,” Kolsrud said.

However, Kolsrud cautioned that the timing and extent of law enforcement involvement would still need to be examined.

If investigators directed or substantially participated in an operation before the confrontation, the legal analysis could change.

Kolsrud believes the complete record of communications between Smith and Predator Poachers could become an important part of the case if it proceeds to trial.

He says defense attorneys will want to examine who initiated conversations, whether multiple people operated the undercover accounts and whether investigators have access to complete digital records.

“Who was the one that initiated the sexualized conversation? Was it the vigilante group or was it the suspect? And who escalated it?” Kolsrud said.

Those questions could become important when determining whether the suspect independently demonstrated an intent to commit a crime or whether the interactions were heavily influenced by the people conducting the sting.

Kolsrud also said members of Predator Poachers could potentially be called to testify about their investigative methods, communications and handling of evidence.

The group’s credibility, motivations and methods could all become subjects of examination by defense attorneys.

Prosecutors requested a $500,000 cash bond, but the judge set Smith’s bond at $100,000, with electronic monitoring and other restrictions required if he were released.

12News requested an interview with Scottsdale police to discuss the advantages and potential problems associated with online predator-catching groups, but the department was unable to make someone available for an interview.

In a statement, Scottsdale police said they do not endorse vigilante groups and encouraged the public to allow trained law enforcement officers to conduct these types of investigations.

Kolsrud says there are legitimate concerns about the motivations of some groups, particularly when their confrontations generate significant online attention.

“I think that you have to be cautious about why these vigilante groups are doing what they’re doing. Are they doing it for the victims? Are they doing it for themselves, for viewerships? And are they cutting corners? You know that’s the real question,” Kolsrud said.

He warned that groups focused primarily on attracting viewers could compromise investigations by improperly handling evidence, escalating confrontations or pressuring suspects into making statements.

Publicizing encounters before criminal proceedings have begun could also complicate jury selection.

At the same time, Kolsrud acknowledged that groups with established records of assisting law enforcement and securing convictions can provide valuable information to prosecutors.

He said each operation should be evaluated individually, with particular attention paid to the credibility of those involved and the integrity of the evidence collected.

Meanwhile, Predator Poachers appears to be continuing its operations across the country.

The group’s social media accounts indicate its members have traveled to Nevada and California in recent days to conduct additional investigations targeting suspected child predators.


Source link

——————————————————–
Click Here For The Original Source.