The earlier kids join social media, the lower their test scores tend to be, study finds | #childpredator | #kidsaftey | #childsaftey

A study of high school students in Lombardy, a region in northern Italy, found that students who created a personal social media account in 6th, 7th, or 8th grade tended to score lower on standardized tests of Italian and mathematics than peers who waited until 9th grade or later. The earlier students opened an account, the larger the gap tended to be. The paper was published in Nature Human Behaviour.
The age at which children should be allowed to start using smartphones and social media has become a subject of intense debate among scientists, educators, and parents. Children are increasingly acquiring their first smartphones at around 10 or 11 years of age, often creating social media accounts before reaching the minimum age required by platforms or national regulations. This trend has raised concerns because increasing digital media use among young people has coincided with declining indicators of mental health and academic performance in many countries.
Research suggests that intensive social media use is associated with poorer sleep, reduced concentration, fewer face-to-face interactions, and lower life satisfaction. However, scientists disagree about whether social media use directly causes these problems, as findings have been inconsistent and many studies cannot establish cause-and-effect relationships.
Studies examining academic performance have generally found small negative associations between social media use and learning outcomes, although much of this research has focused on university students. Another important limitation is that researchers have typically examined how much time young people spend on social media rather than the age at which they first started using it. Consequently, despite growing campaigns encouraging parents to delay their children’s access to smartphones and social media, little is known about whether starting to use social media at an earlier age affects students’ academic achievement.

Free daily newsletter

Don’t miss the next big psychology finding
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.

Study author Marco Gui of the University of Milano-Bicocca and colleagues wanted to estimate the impact of early social media use on students’ learning outcomes throughout their school careers. They hypothesized that early social media use would harm school performance by distracting students and displacing time they would otherwise spend on homework, sleep, or physical activity, and by exposing them to content and relationships that could harm their mental well-being. They also expected the negative effects to grow with longer exposure.
The researchers combined two data sources. The first was the EYES UP survey, a retrospective questionnaire completed by 6,609 students in 10th and 11th grade in Lombardy during the 2023–2024 school year. The second was data from INVALSI, the Italian National Institute for the Evaluation of the Education and Training System, which administers standardized tests in Italian and mathematics in grades 2, 5, 8, 10, and 13, and in English in grades 5 and 8.
The survey asked students in which grade they opened their first social media profile and received their first internet-connected smartphone, as well as when they began independently using a video game console, computer, or tablet. It also assessed how much smartphones intruded on students’ daily lives, along with their well-being, life satisfaction, and academic self-efficacy. After merging the two datasets and focusing on students born in 2007 and 2008, the analytic sample included 5,227 students.
Results showed that the median student started using a video game console in grade 4 and a tablet in grade 5. By grade 6, the median student had independent access to a computer and their own internet-connected smartphone, and 47% of students received their first smartphone that year. By the end of 8th grade, when Italian students finish lower-secondary school, 98% owned a smartphone, and most began using messaging apps when they got their smartphone or the following year, even though most such apps require users to be at least 13 or 14.
When it came to social media, 11% of students opened their first profile during primary school, 30% in 6th grade, 25% in 7th grade, and 18% in 8th grade. Only 16% waited until 9th grade, which corresponds to age 14, the minimum age for independent access under Italian law.
Students who started using social media earlier tended to score lower in Italian and mathematics, even after accounting for their exposure to other forms of technology. However, early adopters also tended to come from less-educated families, were less likely to live with both parents, and already had lower test scores before they opened a social media account.
To better isolate the role of social media, the researchers separately matched students who opened accounts in 6th, 7th, or 8th grade with students who waited until 9th grade or later, pairing them on family background, prior technology use, and 5th-grade test scores and school marks. They then tracked how each group’s test scores changed over time, a method known as difference-in-differences.
Students who opened an account in 6th grade scored about 0.22 standard deviations lower in Italian and 0.18 lower in mathematics by 8th grade than comparable students who waited. By 10th grade, the gap in Italian remained the same and the gap in mathematics grew to 0.27 standard deviations. Differences for students who started in 7th grade were in the same direction but smaller, and differences for those who started in 8th grade were smaller still, with the 8th-grade gap in mathematics not statistically significant.
The findings for students who started in 8th grade were also less robust in additional statistical checks, while the findings for those who started in 6th grade were the most robust. Early social media use was not linked to English test scores, which the authors suggest may reflect the large amount of English-language content online. Students who started in 6th or 7th grade were also more likely to repeat a grade, and all early adopters were less likely to earn top marks at the end of 8th grade and reported lower academic self-efficacy.
An exploratory analysis suggested that the pervasiveness of smartphones in students’ daily lives, such as checking their phones before bed, upon waking, or while doing homework, accounted for roughly 15% to 47% of the link between early social media use and lower test scores, depending on the subject. The authors note that this analysis was correlational.
“The findings of this study carry important implications for educators, parents and policymakers. First, they emphasize the need for more structured guidelines and digital literacy programs in schools aimed at developing appropriate awareness of social media use among young students and parents, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds. Second, they suggest the need to regulate the engagement mechanisms embedded in these platforms, particularly when they are used by minors. Moreover, in the short term, policies that delay social media access until children are cognitively mature enough to manage its potential distractions could be beneficial. Some of these policies are already in place,” the study authors concluded.
The study contributes to the scientific understanding of the links between social media use and academic performance. However, it should be noted that the size of the differences is open to interpretation. The authors note that effects above 0.2 standard deviations are considered large in education research and that a 0.2 standard deviation gap is roughly equivalent to six months of schooling, but by general benchmarks used in psychology, differences of this magnitude are considered small.
Additionally, although the authors interpret their findings as evidence of a causal effect, the study was not an experiment, and its conclusions depend on assumptions that cannot be fully verified, such as the absence of unmeasured factors like family dynamics that influence both social media use and academic performance. The age at which students first used social media was also based on their recollections, leaving room for recall bias, and the sample excluded students in short vocational programs and those who had dropped out or repeated multiple years.
The findings may also not generalize beyond northern Italy or to the social media landscape of 2019 to 2023, when the students in the study were adolescents. Two of the authors, Gui and Chiara Respi, serve on the governance board of the Patti Digitali Foundation, which advocates for a gradual approach to children’s access to digital environments.
The paper, “Longitudinal effect of early social media use on standardized learning outcomes during school career,” was authored by Marco Gui, Chiara Respi, Giovanni Abbiati, Cristiana Paladini, Sofia Ercolanoni, Francesca Milzani, Tiziana Pirola, and Giovanni Vezzoli.


Source link

——————————————————–
Click Here For The Original Source.