A Travis County court will soon hold a trial in Texas’ case against TikTok, following a pretrial ruling in the state’s favor last month. The attorney general’s office has spun the case as a stand for teen safety online, but the state’s requested relief would give the government a say over how citizens can access lawful speech online, and embolden a nanny state seeking to take everyday parenting decisions away from families.TikTok is one name on a long list of companies the state has sued over similar issues, including Snapchat, Roblox and Discord, along with Netflix. The cases, as with Texas’ case against TikTok, are often spun and presented to the public as efforts to enhance teen safety. But rather than taking important steps to improve online safety for minors, they simply aim to grow the government’s role in telling families what media they can consume and when.Deciding how to present lawful media — free speech — to their viewers is the editorial judgment of any media outlet, whether it’s a newspaper or a social media platform. The Supreme Court has held, including in the landmark NetChoice v. Paxton, that the First Amendment protects such editorial decision-making. At trial, however, the judge may allow the government to make some of those choices for Texans.Texas has tried this before. House Bill 18 ordered websites to monitor and censor broad categories of lawful content for minors. In July, a federal appeals court agreed with NetChoice and upheld the lower court’s order blocking the state from enforcing the law.Unfortunately, courts do not always get fundamental free speech issues right. In New Mexico this summer, a judge ordered Meta to show every adult user in the state a message making dubious scientific claims about the impact of social media on mental health.In America’s history, those decisions have belonged to parents and families, not the government — and it should stay that way. Americans understand that precedent. FIRE polling found 69% of Americans say they trust parents to oversee their kids’ social media while 73% distrust the federal government doing so.But the First Amendment does not mean there is no role for government to play in protecting minors online. Government has real, important work to do. Take just one example: online predation. Texas’ Internet Crimes Against Children task force and local police need money to hire staff, conduct investigations and prosecute predators through to conviction.The state can also help parents use the controls already built into their kids’ phones and apps. The Family Online Safety Institute found only about half of parents use parental controls on tablets, and fewer do on phones. A campaign teaching families how those settings work would empower parents to use tools at their disposal more than any judgment the attorney general could secure against TikTok.While many of these social media cases are spun as safety crusades, they represent a huge boon for trial attorneys seeking to profit from controversy surrounding online content. In Paxton’s case against TikTok, he hired private counsel to litigate for him. In fact, there has been no assurance from the state that it will use any funds secured in these lawsuits to tackle the problem of unpunished predators across the internet harming Texan children.These lawsuits would leave government with broadly expanded control over how information and speech are transmitted online. Texans will elect a new attorney general next month, and whoever wins inherits any powers the state obtains to control what information we see online. Decisions about what children see online should stay with their families, not politicians. Robert Winterton is vice president of public affairs at NetChoice, a trade association of online businesses that has challenged Texas’ House Bill 18 in federal court.
————————————————
Source link
